RECTORS OF ST. PAUL'S CHURCH
| November 1865 | - March 1867 | The Reverend Ozi William Whitaker |
| May 1867 | - August 1867 | The Reverend William H. Benjamin |
| November 1867 | - May 1868 | The Reverend John H. Elliott |
| July 1868 | - October 1878 | The Reverend William S. Langford * |
| December 1870 | - November 1880 | The Reverend John William Payne |
| January 1881 | - January 1884 | The Reverend James H. Van Buren ** |
| April 1885 | - April 1887 | The Reverend Charles W. Ward |
| January 1888 | - October 1904 | The Reverend George Frederick Flichtner |
| January 1905 | - October 1911 | The Reverend Harold C. Robbins, D.D. |
| March 1912 | - October 1921 | The Reverend Fleming James, Ph.D., D.D. |
| February 1922 | - December 1932 | The Reverend Joseph Russell Lynes, D.D. |
| October 1933 | - September 1962 | The Reverend James Archibald Mitchell, M.A., D.D. |
| October 1962 | - November 1978 | The Reverend David M. Gillespie |
| August 1979 | - January 1991 | The Reverend Jack M. McKelvey *** |
| November 1991 | - June 2008 | The Reverend Kenneth M. Near |
* Later General Secretary of the Domestic & Foreign Missionary Society
** Later Bishop of Puerto Rico
*** Later Suffragan Bishop of Newark, New Jersey
Then Bishop of Rochester, New York, until his retirement in 2008